Keep knowledgeable with free updates
Merely signal as much as the Pensions business myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.
Ministers are utilizing strong-arm ways to stress pension funds to honour a proposed “voluntary” dedication to speculate extra in UK property, business figures have claimed.
A deal to be signed subsequent month would see pension funds conform to allocate 10 per cent of their property to non-public funds by the tip of the last decade, with half within the UK.
However business executives say the Treasury has warned them it might mandate the requirement if pension funds fail to hit the brand new targets.
“Now we have our arms shoved up behind our backs,” mentioned one pensions govt.
The pensions reforms are a part of a wider collection of Metropolis modifications deliberate by Rachel Reeves. The chancellor would set out a monetary companies technique at her set-piece Mansion Home speech within the Metropolis to be held on July 15, individuals with information of the occasion mentioned.
Reeves needs to mobilise tens of billions of kilos of pension fund property to spice up progress and improve funding in fast-growing corporations, arguing this could additionally improve returns for savers.
Step one, anticipated on Might 6, will see Reeves and pension fund bosses agree voluntary targets — dubbed the “Mansion Home Compact II” — supposed to see extra funds allotted to non-public markets, together with within the UK.
However Reeves and pensions minister Torsten Bell are additionally conducting a separate pensions evaluation that can discover whether or not to introduce new authorized powers by means of the Pensions Schemes invoice this summer season.
Pension fund bosses doubt whether or not ministers would ever resort to utilizing the legislation to inform them the place to speculate, arguing that it could reduce throughout their fiduciary obligation to get the very best return for savers.
However they imagine that different measures resembling league tables or “naming and shaming” might be utilized by ministers.
Former Conservative chancellor Sir Jeremy Hunt, who presided over the primary Mansion Home Compact with pension funds in 2023, mentioned he anticipated Reeves to carry the concept of mandating the measure as a final resort.
“The probably subsequent step just isn’t direct mandation however a public menace that mandation will observe in just a few years if home funding continues to lag [behind] worldwide benchmarks,” Hunt mentioned.
His unique pact in 2023 noticed 11 pension funds agree to speculate not less than 5 per cent of their default fund’s property in non-public markets by 2030. Reeves has made it clear that she needs to set a extra formidable goal.
One pension fund govt mentioned that legally mandating the extent would “open a can of worms”, including: “How can we clarify to savers we’re placing cash into property which have been confirmed, over a time period, to ship a decrease return?”
“I feel there might be a ‘sword of Damocles’ method to encourage better efforts,” mentioned one other business govt. “The brand new goal might be voluntary, however you can create a mechanism in laws that might permit them to make it obligatory.”
The Treasury mentioned it could not “present a working commentary” on its work, however that its evaluation of pensions funding would contemplate whether or not “additional interventions could also be wanted by the federal government” to make sure investments are benefiting UK progress.
